Central Florida BBQ Restaraunt Guide
Menu

Papa Diesels BBQ

Updated 2026-08-18 · 6,088 reviewed · 140 listed · Scored from 32 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.5(32) 66 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
BBQ CateringBBQ Food Truck / StandTexas-Style BBQBBQ BuffetTraditional Smokehouse BBQCarolina-Style BBQ
Papa Diesels BBQ
Services
BBQ Catering, BBQ Food Truck / Stand, Texas-Style BBQ
Reviews
32

What recent reviews say

Most reviewers praise Papa Diesels for tender, well-smoked brisket and ribs that sell out regularly, paired with creative sides like diesel fries and Brussels sprouts. The owner's warmth and care are memorable, though several note the prices are steep for what arrives, and a few experienced oversalted sides or fatty meat that didn't match the five-star meals others raved about.

Praised for
  • tender, flavorful meat
  • generous portions
  • standout sides and unique items
  • friendly owner and staff
  • distinctive smoke flavors and homemade sauces
Watch-outs
  • oversalted food
  • high prices for portion size
  • inconsistent quality between visits
  • fatty cuts of meat on some orders
tender-meatsmoky-flavorfall-off-the-bonegenerous-portionsoverpricedfriendly-staffauthentic-flavorgreat-sauce-optionsinconsistent-qualitygood-sides
Best for: Diners seeking distinctive smoked meats and homemade sauces; worth a trip if you don't mind premium pricing.
Think twice if: Budget-conscious lunch seekers or those sensitive to salt should ask about daily specials and sauce levels beforehand.

Strengths

  • ribs that regularly sell out
  • homemade sauces and distinctive smoke flavors
  • owner actively involved in service and cares about quality
  • unique sides beyond standard BBQ fare

Worth knowing

  • Ribs regularly run out due to demand
  • Homemade sauces stated to be heading into local supermarkets
  • Kiosk ordering with table service
  • Owner involved and known to customers
  • Diesel Sampler includes brisket, ribs, pulled pork, sausage, and chicken
  • Unique sides: diesel fries, Brussels sprouts, corn muffins

What reviews say by service

Traditional Smokehouse BBQ
Brisket and ribs praised for tenderness and flavor; a few complaints of over-smoking or excessive fat.
Texas-Style BBQ
Pulled pork and brisket singled out as among the best experienced by regular barbecue travelers.
Carolina-Style BBQ
Limited direct mentions; sauces and seasoning noted as flavorful and distinctive.
BBQ Catering
Pulled pork catering order (6 pounds) for Super Bowl party well-received by guests.
Rib House / Ribs Specialist
Ribs consistently praised for tenderness and flavor; reported selling out regularly.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.5 against a 4.55 average across the 70 bbq catering businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 19% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

How We Score
Star rating 67
Review volume 66
Review recency 99
Review sentiment 64
Profile completeness 25
Verification 0

Rating breakdown

5
27
4
0
3
1
2
2
1
2

Common questions

Do the ribs ever run out?
Yes, multiple reviewers mention the ribs sell out because they are so popular.
Can I order ribs or sides without the full meal?
Yes; reviewers ordered individual items and sampler plates, though one noted the to-go menu could use more detail on sides and pricing.
Is there catering available?
Yes; one reviewer ordered 6 pounds of pulled pork for a Super Bowl party and guests requested details on the vendor.

Similar bbq restaurants nearby

4 Rivers Smokehouse
81

4 Rivers Smokehouse

4.5(3644)✓ Google-verified

4 Rivers delivers reliably good smoked meats and ribs with staff known for warmth and quick problem-solving. Recent friction centers on rising prices paired with smaller portions and occasional quality dips, particularly in sides like mac and cheese and order execution during busy dinner service.

BBQ CateringTexas-Style BBQBBQ Buffet
Bonefish Grill
77

Bonefish Grill

4.5(2454)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Bonefish Grill in Longwood draws loyal regulars for hand-grilled seafood and a calm setting, with staff often praised for attentiveness. Recent visits reveal inconsistency: some diners enjoy fresh food and professional service, while others report overcooked dishes, salty sauces, mushy vegetables, and facility odors that detract from their meal.

Traditional Smokehouse BBQTexas-Style BBQCarolina-Style BBQ
Gator's Dockside Hunt Club (Apopka)
67

Gator's Dockside Hunt Club (Apopka)

4.0(1626)✓ Google-verified

Half the reviews are five-star praise for staff and events; the other half cite forgotten tables, 80-minute waits, and cold shoulders from servers. When things run smoothly, customers return for bingo nights and wings; when they do not, the experience feels abandoned and the food forgettable.

BBQ CateringBBQ BuffetTraditional Smokehouse BBQ

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-18