Central Florida BBQ Restaraunt Guide
Menu
Check availability

Smokey Jay's BBQ

Updated 2026-08-18 · 6,088 reviewed · 140 listed · Scored from 412 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.9(412) 91 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified moderate
Traditional Smokehouse BBQBBQ CateringCarolina-Style BBQ
Smokey Jay's BBQ
Price
moderate
Services
Traditional Smokehouse BBQ, BBQ Catering, Carolina-Style BBQ
Reviews
412

What recent reviews say

Reviewers consistently praise Smokey Jay's for tender, juicy ribs and brisket that live up to a day-later craving. Jay, the owner, earns praise for genuine hospitality; staff deliver attentive service and the sides-especially mac and cheese and collard greens-stand on their own.

The small, homey dining room matches the mom-and-pop feel. Prices and portion sizes draw repeat customers from across Central Florida, though early-day stock-outs happen. Most leave planning their next visit.

Praised for
  • tender, fall-off-bone ribs
  • flavorful brisket and pulled pork
  • homemade sides (mac and cheese, greens, beans)
  • welcoming owner and friendly staff
  • generous portions and fair pricing
Watch-outs
  • occasional stock-outs (brisket sold out by day's end)
tender-meatfall-off-the-bonegenerous-portionsfair-pricingfriendly-staffauthentic-flavorgood-sidesfamily-friendlyclean-dining-area
Best for: customers seeking authentic, homemade barbecue with attentive ownership and generous portions
Think twice if: ordering signature items early in the day to avoid sold-out brisket

Strengths

  • slow-smoked meats with fall-off-bone tenderness
  • homemade, award-worthy sides (mac and cheese, collard greens)
  • owner-led hospitality and generous service
  • fair pricing for portion size and quality

Worth knowing

  • Owner Jay personally greets and serves guests
  • homemade pound cake offered
  • South Carolina mustard-based sauce available alongside standard sauces
  • loaded fries and smokehouse fries mentioned as standouts
  • catering and event catering services available

What reviews say by service

Traditional Smokehouse BBQ
ribs consistently praised for tenderness and flavor; brisket and pulled pork equally tender and juicy
BBQ Catering
catering services offered; website claims event catering available across multiple Central Florida areas
Carolina-Style BBQ
South Carolina mustard-based sauce specifically praised by reviewers; collard greens and other traditional sides included

How it compares

  • Rated 4.9 against a 4.51 average across the 124 traditional smokehouse bbq businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 46% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

How We Score
Star rating 92
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 75
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
395
4
10
3
4
2
1
1
2

Common questions

What kind of sauce does Smokey Jay's use?
They offer multiple sauce options including a South Carolina-style mustard-based sauce that reviewers specifically praised.
Does Smokey Jay's do catering?
Yes, their website lists catering and event catering services available across Kissimmee, Curry Ford West, UCF, Disney Springs, Lake Buena Vista, International Drive, Mills 50, and Maitland.
Do they have sides beyond the meat?
Yes. Reviewers highlight mac and cheese, collard greens, beans, and loaded smokehouse fries as standouts, plus homemade pound cake.
Request a quote

Similar bbq restaurants nearby

Sonny's BBQ
87

Sonny's BBQ

4.6(4088)✓ Google-verified

Laura and the Winter Park team earn consistent praise for attentiveness, warmth, and genuine enthusiasm. Food quality and cleanliness round out a no-friction dining experience locals return to repeatedly. The restaurant operates across Winter Park, Oviedo, and Apopka with dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside options. Their website states 50 years of tradition behind slow-smoked BBQ, sandwiches, and family meals, plus catering for larger needs.

BBQ CateringTexas-Style BBQCarolina-Style BBQ
View profile
City Barbeque
87

City Barbeque

4.7(2435)✓ Google-verified

Staff greet regulars by name and go out of their way to make guests feel welcomed; the brisket, pulled pork, and ribs earn consistent praise for moisture and flavor. Catering arrives early, portions are generous, and the newer dining space is clean and modern. One reviewer's incomplete order was corrected on the spot, though busy times can cause slip-ups.

BBQ BuffetTexas-Style BBQBBQ Catering
View profile
Izziban Sushi & BBQ
63 low data

Izziban Sushi & BBQ

4.3(5628)✓ Google-verified

Izziban Sushi & BBQ has built a strong following in Orlando since 2007, with 5,628 reviews averaging 4.3 stars and 68% five-star ratings. Review evidence is limited to topic tags rather than full texts.

Korean / Asian BBQTraditional Smokehouse BBQBBQ Catering
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-18