Central Florida BBQ Restaraunt Guide
Menu

St Johns River Steak & Seafood

Updated 2026-08-18 · 6,088 reviewed · 140 listed · Scored from 3,716 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.3(3716) 73 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified moderate
Traditional Smokehouse BBQBBQ Buffet
St Johns River Steak & Seafood
Price
moderate
Services
Traditional Smokehouse BBQ, BBQ Buffet
Reviews
3716

What recent reviews say

A lakefront Sanford dining spot where the setting and service shine consistently, but food execution stumbles on fried items. Staff eagerness and management attention win over most diners, particularly those celebrating occasions. Steaks and fresh preparations get praise; fried seafood and sides draw complaints about texture, seasoning, and consistency. Views of Lake Monroe and St. Johns River anchor the appeal, though some note the space looks dated.

Strengths sit in hospitality and ambiance rather than kitchen reliability. Multiple reviewers praise servers by name and highlight manager gestures like personally assisting guests. Yet recent fried platters arrived with watery scallops, dried grouper, and overseasoned breading. The restaurant responds to complaints, but some diners felt dismissed rather than made whole. Pricing sits moderate to high relative to comparable Sanford spots.

Praised for
  • lakefront views and atmosphere
  • attentive and friendly staff
  • fresh seafood and quality steaks
  • manager engagement and personal touches
Watch-outs
  • inconsistent seafood quality and preparation
  • dry or over-fried items
  • poor handling of complaints and no bill adjustments
  • worn decor needs updating
friendly-staffgenerous-portionsclean-dining-areainconsistent-qualitydry-meatgood-sides
Best for: Couples and groups celebrating occasions who prioritize setting and service over consistent kitchen execution.
Think twice if: You order fried seafood platters frequently or expect reliable results on battered items; recent reviews flag watery scallops, dried fish, and breading issues.

Strengths

  • Lake Monroe and river views from dining areas
  • attentive staff and hands-on management
  • fresh seafood quality on broiled items
  • celebrates special occasions with complimentary cake

Worth knowing

  • Manager personally assists guests with items like bib placement
  • Named server Katie praised for knowledge
  • Restaurant compliments birthday guests with a complimentary cake slice
  • Reviewer noted to-go containers are low-quality
  • Recent take-out fried orders included watery scallops, over-fried oysters, and under-seasoned grouper

What reviews say by service

Traditional Smokehouse BBQ
Limited evidence; grilled jerk pork chop praised, but fried seafood platters show inconsistency.
BBQ Buffet
No clear buffet service mentioned in reviews; business website lists steak and seafood but not buffet.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.3 against a 4.51 average across the 124 traditional smokehouse bbq businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 94% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

How We Score
Star rating 53
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
2341
4
688
3
284
2
153
1
250

Common questions

Do you offer specials for birthdays?
Yes; the restaurant compliments birthday guests with a complimentary slice of cake.
What is the view like from the dining area?
The restaurant overlooks Lake Monroe and the St. Johns River; reviewers recommend the patio, especially at sunset.
How far is it from Sanford airport?
Approximately 15 minutes, according to a recent diner.

Similar bbq restaurants nearby

Sonny's BBQ
87

Sonny's BBQ

4.6(4827)✓ Google-verified

Food is consistently praised as high-quality and flavorful, with pit-smoked ribs and slow-smoked meats standing out. Service shines across recent visits, especially from servers like Jillian and Savannah, who anticipate needs without being asked and treat customers like family.

Texas-Style BBQTraditional Smokehouse BBQCarolina-Style BBQ
Keys Q BBQ Company
56 low data

Keys Q BBQ Company

5.0(11)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

All 11 reviewers gave five stars. They consistently describe the meat as juicy and tender, praise the sides (mango slaw, mac and cheese, baked beans) and homemade sauces, and repeatedly recommend catering for corporate events. Armando's attention to detail and unique flavors stand out across multiple accounts.

BBQ CateringBBQ BuffetBBQ Food Truck / Stand

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-18